---
title: Improvement Era
description: Monthly periodical of the Mormon church, 1897 onward. This library holds the issues of November 1897 to December 1930.
authors:
  - Van Buren, C. G.
collections:
  - periodicals
tags:
  - magazine
  - improvement-era
periodical: Improvement Era
volume: 10
number: 12
published: 1907-10
publisher: Young Men’s Mutual Improvement Associations
publisher_place: Salt Lake City
language: en
type: magazine
reference: 'C. G. Van Buren, "Germination of the Cocklebur," *Improvement Era* 10, no. 12 (October 1907): 981–983.'
source:
  url: https://archive.org/details/improvementera10012unse
  transcription: Transcribed from the Internet Archive scan of each issue (the item for each issue is named in the issue's own source); unnumbered advertising leaves are omitted, printed page numbers are kept as page markers.
  identifier: improvementera10012unse
start_page: 981
end_page: 983
rights:
  status: public-domain
  basis: US publication 1930 or earlier (published 1907-10)
  source: https://archive.org/details/improvementera10012unse
  publication_year: 1907
  note: The Internet Archive item metadata carries a blanket "© Copyright by Intellectual Reserve, Inc." notice. The library owner judged it inapplicable because this issue was published in 1907, before 1931; a scan-level notice does not restore copyright.
---

# Germination of the Cocklebur

<!-- page:981 -->

GERMINATION OF THE COCKLEBUR.
BY C. G. VAN BUREN, B. S., OF THE BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY.
Most farmers know that each cocklebur bears two seeds, and
many of them have probably noticed that one of these seeds (the
lower one) sprouts, or germinates, the first year, and the other (the
upper or the one nearest the apex of the bur) germinates the sec-
ond year. This peculiarity has lead to much speculation, and for
a long time has puzzled botanists. The most frequent cause of
delayed germination is the water-proof character of the seed coats
which hinders the entrance of water, and when moisture is excluded
germination cannot take place. However, it was shown that both
seeds of the cocklebur imbibed about an equal amount of water,
therefore that could not account for the difference. At length it
was suggested that "enzymes" (ferments which have the peculiar
property of changing starch into sugar) were readily produced in
the lower seeds, but in the upper ones only after a long period of
rest. These enzymes digest the food for the young plants, hence
those seeds having them could begin growth immediately, while
those seeds without them could begin growth only after one or
more years.
To test this theory Mr. Wm. Crocker began work in the Hull
Botanical Laboratory of the University of Chicago. He obtained
only negative results, but accidentally discovered that the seed
would germinate at a high temperature; also that some of them,
whose coverings were damaged while being removed from the bur,
began to germina*-e at lower temperatures. These discoveries led
to a new line of experiments which demonstrated some interesting
facts. Mr. Crocker found that at 22 to 24° Centigrade (72.6 to
76.2° Fahrenheit) 99 per cent of the lower seeds germinated but

<!-- page:982 -->

982 IMPROVEMENT ERA.
none of the upper ones. At a temperature of 32-34° C. (90.6-
94-2° F.) 100 per cent of the lower seeds and 99 per cent of the
upper ones germinated. He then removed the seed coats and
found that all the seeds, the upper as well as the lower ones, would
germinate at 18-22° C. (65.4-72.6° F.) The lowest temperature at
which the lower seeds would germinate with the seed coats on was
21° C. (70.8° F.); the lowest, or minimum temperature for the
upper seeds fluctuated between 25° and 41° C. (78-106.8° F.) but
both the lower and the upper seeds, with the seed coats removed,
germinated at a temperature as low as 18° C. (65.4° F.). This
was evidence enough to show that the seed coats and not the
enzymes caused the delay in germination.
The next thing to do was to find out why the seed coats re-
tarded germination. Besides warmth, seed must have moisture and
air (oxygen) in order to germinate; evidently, then, the seed coats
prevented the entrance of either water or oxygen.
Mr. Crocker found that both the upper and lower seeds imbibed
about the same amount of water in a given time, so it became evi-
dent that the delay was not due to the lack of moisture. By soak-
ing the upper seeds and then placing them in a jar of oxygen at a
temperature of 21-23° C. (70-8-74.4° F.) all germinated in six days.
Further experiments showed that at 23° C. (74.4° F.) the lower
seeds would take up 1.6 to 1.7 times as much oxygen with the
seed coats removed as with them intact, while the upper seeds took
up 2 to 2.4 times as much oxygen with the seed coats removed as
with them intact.
As a temperature of 32° C. (90.6° F.) is rather unusual in the
springtime, and as man, or any other animal, so far as we know, is
not particularly concerned in removing the seed coats, the question
naturally arises: why should these seeds germinate at all in nature?
Mr. Crocker has not forgotten this interesting feature. He took:
1st, a quantity of seed just gathered; 2nd, seed that had been stored
in the laboratory one year; and 3rd, seed that had been stored four
months in the laboratory and then buried eight| months in the
ground. On placing these seeds under germinating conditions he
found after a period of thirty days at a temperature of 28-33° C.
(83.4-92.4° F.) 3 per cent of the first lot germinated, none of the
second lot, but of the seed that had been buried eight months 96

<!-- page:983 -->

GERMINATION OF THE COCKLEBUR. 983
per cent were growing. He then removed the seed coats from other
quantities of seeds taken as above, and in 33 days, at a temperature
of 18-22° C, (65.4-72.6° F.) all of the seeds just gathered and
those stored in the laboratory one year had germinated, but only
94 per cent of the seed that had been buried for eight months.
These experiments show that when buried in the earth the seed
coats undergo a change, and permit the passage of oxygen, but the
"vitality" of the seed is slightly impaired.
Under the microscope the coats of the upper seeds are shown
to be a little thicker than those of the lower ones, and the burs
around them are harder and do not decay so soon, hence the ability
of the upper seeds to delay germination under natural conditions.
There no one but can see how admirably the cockleburs are
is
adapted to cling to the fur of passing animals, and thus secure the
distribution of their seeds in space, but even more admirable is this
other quality which enables it to distribule its offspring through
time.
Provo, Utah.
